No one in the St. Joseph County Republican Party had a good night on Nov. 3. Every Republican running countywide lost, and the party gave up three seats on the County Council.
A loss like that sends people looking for someone to blame. For the three lost seats on the County Council, Republicans do not have to look far. Joe Thomas, Amy Drake, and Jamie O’Brien, the Republicans running for those seats in Districts A, B, and C, ran campaigns separate from the St. Joseph County Republican Party, with their own PAC, their own money, and their own “paid for” disclaimers.
Mike Castellon, the incumbent Republican county assessor, did the opposite. He worked with the county party in his bid for re-election.
Castellon had to spread his time and money across all of St. Joseph County. Even so, Castellon drew 344 more votes than Thomas in Thomas’s district, 52 more than Drake in Drake’s, and 193 more than O’Brien in O’Brien’s. O’Brien lost the District C seat to Democrat Jan Cervelli by 376 votes.
Castellon also beat his Democratic challenger, Vic Cummings, in District C, 5,338 to 5,262. If 189 voters had switched from Cervelli to O’Brien, O’Brien would have won the seat. Castellon drew 193 more votes than O’Brien in District C. The seat was within reach.
Castellon outpolled the statewide Republicans in St. Joseph County, too. He received 33,280 votes here. That was 1,380 more than Daniel Elliott, the Republican nominee for state treasurer, 3,834 more than Elise Nieshalla, the nominee for state comptroller, and 6,011 more than Max Engling, the nominee for secretary of state. No Republican on the countywide ballot received more votes in St. Joseph County than Castellon.
County Clerk Amy Rolfes also worked with the county party, which gave her campaign $4,325 this year, most of it in printed palm cards. Rolfes finished second among Republicans in St. Joseph County with 32,422 votes, ahead of every Republican running statewide. She also drew more votes than Thomas in District A and more than O’Brien in District C.
Castellon also spent far less money than the council slate, making the case for the county party even stronger. O’Brien’s campaign reported spending $151,901.33 through Oct. 9 to campaign in one district. Castellon’s campaign reported $63,434.58 over the same period to cover the whole county.
The St. Joseph County Republican Party gave Castellon’s campaign $4,225 this year, mostly in commercials, and his campaign paid the party $8,000 in August. The reports Thomas, Drake, and O’Brien filed list no money to or from the county party.
Sources close to the campaigns say Castellon and other countywide Republicans worked with the county party and its consultants on strategy and on i360, voter-data software campaigns use to organize door-knocking and phone calls. The council slate chose not to use the software the party provided, according to the same sources, and its volunteers worked from paper walk lists and call sheets. The state party and U.S. Rep. Rudy Yakym have offered door-to-door voter data to local Republicans in past election cycles, the sources say, and the slate appears not to have used that either.
The slate had more money than Castellon and fewer votes. Thomas, Drake, and O’Brien went into the election with three Republican council seats and came out with none.
The Democrats ran as one party from the top of the ticket down and won every countywide office, some of them to their own surprise. “I didn’t think I would see what we saw here tonight,” Sheriff Bill Redman told WVPE after he beat Republican Commissioner Carl Baxmeyer for the District 1 commissioner seat.
Democratic voters held up their end. Of the 77,909 ballots cast in the county, 49,335 were straight-ticket, according to the county’s election results, and Democratic straight-ticket ballots outnumbered Republican ballots by 10,352. Cummings won the assessor’s office by 9,656, fewer votes than that straight-ticket margin. Elizabeth Bennion told WVPE that Democrats at every level ran on the same slogan: “Blue No Matter Who.”
Castellon worked with the county party, spent less, and still outpolled all three council Republicans in their own districts. The three who ran on their own lost all three Republican seats. The Democrats who ran together won every countywide office. When the city races come around in 2027, I hope unity is on the Republican ticket.
Logan Foster
Logan Foster is the founder and editor of Redress South Bend, an independent news outlet covering local government, courts, and public institutions in South Bend and St. Joseph County, Indiana. He reports from primary documents: public records requests, court filings, state audit reports, and campaign finance disclosures. His reporting has examined city and school district payments made without competitive bidding, school board spending, and the records of candidates in county races. Redress South Bend obtained the South Bend Police Department's ShotSpotter coverage map after the department initially denied public access. The outlet is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and the Online News Association. Reach him at info@redresssouthbend.com

